THE PULLEY.
When God at first made
man,
Having a glass of
blessings standing by,
“Let us,” said he,
“pour on him all we can.
Let the world’s
riches, which dispersèd lie,
Contract into a
span.”
So strength first made
a way;
Then beauty flowed,
then wisdom, honour, pleasure.
When almost all was
out, God made a stay,
Perceiving that, alone
of all his treasure,
Rest in the bottom
lay.
“For if I should,”
said he,
“Bestow this jewel
also on my creature,
He would adore my
gifts instead of me,
And rest in Nature,
not the God of Nature;
So both should losers
be.
“Yet let him keep the
rest,
But keep them with
repining restlessness;
Let him be rich and
weary, that at least,
If goodness lead him
not, yet weariness
May toss him to my breast.”
About
the Poet
George Herbert was born in to a noble Welsh family
on April 3, 1593. His poetry was influenced chiefly by the puritanical stance
of the 17th century in which he was born. After graduation from the University,
he was ordained as a priest and served in a little church in Bemerton. His
major collection of poems titled “The Temple” was published after his death.
George Herbert was an Anglican priest, theologian,
and poet. Born into a wealthy family, he was very well educated and attended
Trinity College in Cambridge. He briefly served in Parliament in 1624-25. In
his mid-thirties, he gave up his secular career and was ordained a priest in
the Church of England. He served as rector of a small parish 75 miles southwest
of London and was known for his dedication to his parishioners and those who
were needy and ill.
Herbert was a remarkable preacher and a brilliant
writer of religious poems, many of which were put into popular hymns. He wrote
in Greek, Latin, and English. Known for his humility, quiet devotion and
saintly character, Herbert died on the 1stof March 1633.
Structure
of the Poem
The poem
does not hold a specific rhythm. It has 4 stanzas of the poem, the first and
the last lines of each stanza are of equal trimeter but the second, third, and
fourth are not clearly equal in each stanza.
The poem
“The Pulley” by George Herbert has a to total of 20 lines, each line with end
rhyme pattern of ABABA, CDCDC. The first stanza is about the reason God
endowed man during creation, the second stanza showed all the endowments, the
third stanza is about the reason God gave man a companion, the last stanza is
about how all the blessings and possessions given will lead man back to God’s
bosom.
Analysis
of the Poem
The poem
that reveals that when God created man, he created him with lots of blessings
like strength, beauty, wisdom, honour, pleasure but then, He placed man under a
contract that will put him and his possessions to an end at certain period of
time:
The
first stanza describes how God made man and blessed him with worldly riches:
“When God at first made man, Having a glass of blessings standing by”. The
stanza also portrays the concept of Trinity as seen in the Biblical creation
story in Genesis: “Let us, said he pour on him all we can” (Note the use of the
phrase “Let us”).
In the
second stanza, God actually poured his blessings of strength, beauty, wisdom,
honour and pleasure on man but withheld one important blessing- The Gift of
Rest: “Perceiving that, alone of all his treasure, Rest in the bottom lay”.
In the
third stanza, God gave his reason for withholding the gift of rest from man. He
withdrew this blessing because he felt giving man the gift of rest would make
him conceited or excessively proud and man may not worship him: “He would adore
my gifts instead of me, And rest in nature, not the God of Nature”.
In the
fourth stanza, man is thrown into perpetual restlessness so that he can
always remember his creator and turn back to him, whether as a result of
goodness or weariness. “Let him be rich and weary, that at least, If goodness
lead him not, yet weariness may toss him to my breast” .
Mood and Tone
The mood as well as the tone is reflective. The poem is a product of the poet’s
long, quiet and thoughtful reflection on the Biblical creation story.
The Pulley by George
Herbert: Summary and Analysis
The Pulley by George Herbert is a religious, metaphysical
poem which centers on the ‘pulley’ as a prime conceit in the poem. Herbert
wants to unveil the truth that why human beings are so restless and
unsatisfying despite having all the things he wants.
After God made this universe, he gathered all the blessings
of the world in a glass and distributed them to the human beings one after
another. First, he gave the strength, therefore human became strong enough to
survive. One by one, god gave them the beauty, wisdom, honor, pleasure and many
other blessings. When almost all was gone, God kept ‘rest’ at the bottom of the
glass, thinking that ‘both should losers be’ if the ‘rest’ is given. When they
get all they want, in the sense of sufficiency, they may forget God. On one
hand, when human beings get rest, they forget god and take a rest. As a result,
god will lose the love and affection of human beings. On the other hand,
when rest is given, people will lose strength, honor, wisdom and beauty and all
other human capacities. God knows the man is by birth prone to lethargy. They
will get rest at the cost of the progress. Progress and the rest never come
together. We get one losing the other. God is sure that man will only praise
the things God has given to them not the god himself. Mankind will lose their
essence, get tired and wander in search of rest.
In the concluding part of the poem, Herbert gives two reasons
behind human going to god. First, they will go to God out of the goodness,
faith or divine emotions and inborn loyalty for him. Secondly, if they do not
go to god out of the first cause, they will go to him when they are tired.
Weariness takes human beings to the shadow of god. So, the God decides to keep
the mankind away from the rest so as to make him feel the eternal rest can only
be found in God. For the sake of the rest, at least man will remember to god
and go to him for his love and rest. The repining restlessness or the
discontentment with the worldly things will finally lead a man to god. He
wanted man to discover the real rest only in Him. He alone can truly give the
mankind the rest they frantically seek.
The poet answers in a simple tone that the reason behind man
being so unsatisfying and weary is that God has not bestowed us with his
precious jewel ‘rest’, but kept the jewel ‘rest’ with him. So for the sake of
rest, we always run from here to there. We think now we are complete because we
have everything, but the moment we feel so, another moment we feel empty and
become restless. This is what exactly God wants us to be. If this happens to us
then only we remember god and go to him for the ‘rest.’
The title of the poem the pulley is a conceit that carries
the theme of the poem. In pulley from the mechanical point of view to operate
it a kind of power and force has to be applied to one end to lift the object of
the other end. The force applied makes a difference to the weight that is being
lifted. The ‘rest’ that god keeps with him is the leverage that draws the
mankind towards god. Two quite different objects are forcefully compared here,
one from the pure physics that is pulley and the other from the pure religion
that is God. The relationship of man and god is compared with the metaphorical
pulley. To pull mankind back to the God, back to his origin, God keeps man away
from the ‘rest.’ This can only be possible in the metaphysical conceits. So the
title is thematic.
Commentary
The poem is built around the conceit of imagining God in the
process of making human beings. It has echoes of the story of creation in the
opening of the Bible, the first chapter of the Book of Genesis. (Herbert uses
the word “man” in the sense of “humankind” as was typical of all writers in his
era.)
The poem imagines God adding different qualities to this new
creation, pouring them in as a cook might pour ingredients in a cake. He is a
generous Creator. All His blessings, all the world’s riches, are given to
humankind, except for one.
“Rest” in the Christian tradition is one of God’s gifts.
Jesus said “Come to me all that are weary and carrying heavy burdens, and I
will give you rest.” (Matthew 11.28) “Rest” is also used as a picture of the
destiny God promises to those who walk in His way, a picture of heaven. It is a
precious “jewell”.
God pauses before He adds this final gift. If He gives this,
people may “adore my gifts instead of me”. Some commentators have seen this as
God being manipulative, not giving human beings the gift of rest so as to make
them turn to Him. Herbert’s response is in the final line of that verse. If
someone finds satisfaction in God’s gifts and does not come to know God
Himself, then both God and the person are impoverished, “both should losers
be”..
He starts the final verse with a pun playing on another
meaning of the word “rest” - “remainder, what is left”. Human beings are both
richly endowed, but also “wearie” – dissatisfied, tired of what they have. And
this weariness tosses – flings – them into God’s embrace, like a restless,
unhappy child wanting to be hugged and flinging itself into its father’s arms.
Brief Analysis of Herbert's Conceit of The Pulley
It would be difficult to explain Herbert's poem without alluding to Pandora's
box of gifts. The gods, especially Zeus, gave Pandora a box, warning her never
to open it. Her curiosity overcame her, however, and she opened it, releasing
innumerable plagues and sorrows into the world. Only Hope, the one good thing
the box had contained, remained to comfort humanity in its misfortunes. In this
poem, the fusion of the classical and the Christian add richness and dimension
to the poem's guiding metaphysical conceit, which is a pulley that draws man
slowly toward God.
Pulleys and hoists are mechanical devices aimed at assisting us with moving
heavy loads through a system of ropes and wheels (pulleys) to gain advantage.
We should not be surprised at the use of a pulley as a central conceit since
the domain of physics and imagery from that discipline would have felt quite
comfortable to most of the metaphysical poets.
In the poem, the central idea posited by Herbert is that when God made man, he
poured all his blessings on him, including strength, beauty, wisdom, honor and
pleasure. However, as in Pandora's box, one element remained. We are told that
God "made a stay," that is, He kept "Rest in the bottome."
We might, in modern parlance, call this God's ace. God is aware that if He were
to bestow this "jewel" (i.e. rest) on Man as well then Man would
adore God's gifts instead of God Himself. God has withheld the gift of rest
from man knowing fully well that His other treasures would one day result in a
spiritual restlessness and fatigue in man who, having tired of His material
gifts, would necessarily turn to God in his exhaustion. God, being omniscient
and prescient, knows that there is the possibility that even the wicked might
not turn to Him, but He knows that eventually mortal man is prone to lethargy;
his lassitude, then, would be the leverage He needed to toss man to His breast.
In the context of the mechanical operation of a pulley, the kind of leverage
and force applied makes the difference for the weight being lifted. Applied to
man in this poem, we can say that the withholding of Rest by God is the
leverage that will hoist or draw mankind towards God when other means would
make that task difficult. However, in the first line of the last stanza,
Herbert puns on the word "rest" suggesting that perhaps God will,
after all, let man "keep the rest," but such a reading would seem to
diminish the force behind the poem's conceit.
The importance of rest -and, by association, sleep- is an idea that was
certainly uppermost in the minds of Renaissance writers. Many of Shakespeare's
plays include references to sleep or the lack of it as a punishment for sins
committed. In
Macbeth, for example, the central protagonist is said
to "lack the season of all natures, sleep" and both Lady Macbeth and
Macbeth are tormented by the lack of sleep. Even Othello is most disconcerted
by the fact that he is unable to sleep peacefully once Iago has poisoned him
with the possibility of his wife's infidelity with Cassio.
Herbert's
Pulley, then, does not present a new concept. In fact,
the ideas in the poem are quite commonplace for seventeenth century religious
verse. What is distinctly metaphysical about the poem is that a religious
notion is conveyed through a secular, scientific image that requires the
reader's acquaintance with, and understanding of, some basic laws of physics.
In
the style of the “wit” of metaphysical poetry—the ability to see striking,
original analogies and to use fresh metaphors—Herbert writes of man’s
relationship to God by comparing the communication of God to man and man to God
to the movements of a pulley. In the language of seventeenth century poetry,
Herbert uses a “conceit,” an unexpected image from another realm of learning to
illuminate a truth of theology—the simple machine of a pulley from the science
of physics as a concept to understand the mystery of love between God and man.
The first stanza describes God’s gifts from above descending to man below:
When God at first made man,
Having a glass of blessings standing by;
Let us (said he) pour on him all we can:
Let the world’s riches, which dispersed lie,
Contract into a span.
Beginning
with the story of Creation in Genesis, Herbert portrays God as the bountiful
Lord whose goodness overflows with the fullness David praises in Psalm 23: “My
cup runneth over.” God’s blessings know no limits, for He chooses to “pour on
him all we can” and offer man “the world’s riches.” God’s riches abound with a
wealth of plentiful gifts that Herbert describes as the best prizes of human
happiness:
So strength first made a way;
Then beauty flowed, then wisdom, honour, pleasure:
When almost all was out, God made a stay,
Perceiving that alone of all his treasure
Rest in the bottom lay.
God
in the liberality of his munificence bestows this kingly wealth upon his
creature, sparing none of his treasure. God endows man with an abundant life
enriched with the gratification of the senses, the pleasures of the mind, the
wonder of beauty, and the compliments of praise. God empties and pours with
openhanded profusion but withholds one last blessing that remains in the cup:
peace (“Rest in the bottom lay”). God’s love and wisdom complement each other.
To grant man rest in addition to other blessings separates God and man and
eliminates the communion between the Creator and his creature.
In
his infinite wisdom Go does not part with this last gift—his “jewel”—to prevent
man’s self-sufficiency and independence from God, as if man’s ultimate and
final happiness consisted of worldly satisfactions without any thought of
Heaven, eternal happiness, the Beatific Vision, or the “peace that passes all
understanding.” God in his great wisdom gives man temporal pleasure, joy, and
happiness but not perfect “rest”—the peace that Christ promises when He says,
“Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I
give to you” (John 14:27):
For if I should (said he)
Bestow this jewel also on my creature,
He would adore my gifts instead of me,
And rest in Nature, not the God of Nature:
So both should losers be.
From
the heights of Heaven God—as if by means of a pulley—sends down to man on earth
this multitude of gifts. The heavy weight and number of blessings from heaven
above move the pulley downward for man’s benefit and enjoyment, yet God does
not put so much weight on his end that the pulley drops all the gifts to touch
the earth. He designs the pulley to move downward and bestow many gifts to his
creatures yet remain partially suspended. God stops at letting the pulley rest
on earth lest man forget the donor of the gifts, fail to express gratitude, or
lose his relationship with God. Without the pulley moving always both downward
and upward, God’s Providence does not reach man and man’s praise never rises to
God: “both should losers be.” Some of the weight—rest, the “jewel”—remains at
the top end of the pulley to pull the rope up when man falls victim to the
temptation to “rest in Nature, not the God of Nature”—to make the City of Man
the City of God or to think man does not need God. God does not want man to
live as if God does not exist, and a Heavenly Father does not wish to sever his
bond with his children. If man fails to render thanks to God as the author of
all gifts and blessings or forgets the purpose of the human pilgrimage and the
four last things, then God has another way to lead man to him:
Yet let him keep the rest,
But keep them with repining restlessness:
Let him be rich and weary, that at least,
If goodness lead him not, yet weariness
May toss him to my breast.
In
the course of human life the original gifts bestowed from the cup of
blessings—strength, pleasure, beauty, honor, pleasure—do not provide lasting
happiness but “repining restlessness.” Health declines and strength diminishes.
Pleasures fade, and the senses are dulled or jaded. Beauty blooms and then
declines. Honor gives momentary glory but then disappears into oblivion. As
time progresses and ageing follows, these original pleasures do not provide the
deep satisfaction or spiritual joy that offers the rest or peace the heart
seeks. Fading and declining, they lose their weight, and the bottom end of the
pulley becomes lighter and lighter. As these pleasures lose their capacity to
fill man with the happiness he seeks, he grows “weary,” restless, and empty.
The weight that remained in the top part of the pulley—now heavier than the
lower part—pulls upward, and God leads man back to him by the second method—the
way of “weariness” that God has designed when gratitude fails to render to God
the things that are God’s.
The
poem illuminates the journey of St. Augustine’s soul in the Confessions.
Blessed with a loving mother, St. Monica, who never ceased praying for her
son’s conversion, and with a generous father, Patricius, who afforded his son
the best classical education of the day, Augustine—before his
conversion—enjoyed all the blessings enumerated in Herbert’s poem: health,
friendship, pleasure, honor, and wisdom. He achieved the prestige of a
professor of rhetoric, pursued a love of knowledge, and felt inspired by “an
extraordinary and burning love of wisdom.” He reveled in the entertainments of
his pagan culture, enjoyed gladiatorial spectacles, “was carried away by plays
on the stage,” cultivated the ideals of friendship, and cohabited “with a woman
who was not bound to me by marriage.” Despite honor, wisdom, and pleasure
Augustine confesses, “I lived a life in which I was seduced and seducing,
deceived and deceiving, the prey of various desires.” He writes, “Mad and
foolish I was at that time. I raged and sighed and wept and worried, I could
not rest, I could not think intelligently.” Although God’s many gifts and
life’s pleasures never lifted Augustine’s heart to gratitude, his restlessness
ultimately led him to the Catholic faith where his restless found rest: “Stand
in Him, and you shall stand fast; rest in Him, and you shall find peace.”
Herbert’s concluding line, “If goodness lead him not, yet weariness/ May toss
him to my breast” gives special meaning to Augustine’s most famous words: “Our
hearts are restless until they find their rest in you.”
GEORGE HERBERT - THE
PULLEY ,
1. How many
stanzas it has? Four stanzas
2. Who gave
Pandora Box? Zeus.
3. How many
lines each stanza contains? Five lines.
4. In which does
god keep gifts? Glass.
5. What would
happen if god gave rest to man? Man would rest in nature and not the god of
nature.
6. Which will
make man towards god? Weariness.
7. What is the
first gift that God gives a man? Strength
8. Name the
gifts that God gives man. Strength,
beauty, wisdom, pleasure.
9. What is the
gift that God does not give man? Rest or peace of mind.
10. Why does God
withhold rest from man? To make man seek peace by communing with God, God
denied him peace.
11. What is a pulley?
It is a mechanical device. It raises heavy objects to a higher level.
12. What is compared
to pulley? God who lifts care-worn people to higher spiritual planes is
regarded as a pulley.
13. What is the
another name of ‘Pulley’? The gifts of god.
14. What is the collection of work of
Herbert? ‘The Temple’.
15. What does the
word Pulley refer? Pain, Bliss and
struggle.
16. What are the two
things add richness to metaphysical conceit?
The fusion of the classical and
the Christian.
17. What is the
central idea of the poem? God made man,
he poured all his blessings on him. However, as in Pandora’s box one element
remained.
18. Where is God
kept the Rest? At the Bottome.
19. Why is God not
bestowed Rest on man? If he were to bestow on man as well then Man would adore
God’s gifts instead of God Himself.
20. What poetic
device does Herbert use in the first stanza? Pun.
21. Whose age people
writings are reflected in this poem?
Renaissance
22. How is Rest
compared? Jewel
23. What meter is
used in this poem? Iambic Pentameter.
24. Who said “Let
man fret and worry himself”? God
25. What is the
first line of the poem? “When God at first made man”.
THE AFFLICTION
1. Which
is Herbert’s autobiographical poem? The
Affliction
2. What
is the poem about? It is account of his spiritual life up to the present.
3. Why
the poem is entitled as ‘Affliction’? His early life was joyful and believing
in God but subsequently he has been overshadowed by suffering.
4. What
did he complain about? His troubles and sufferings.
5. What
does Affliction refer? Tuberculosis due to which Herbert died.
6. What
does Herbert use in the last lines of the poem? Forgetfulness.